Welcome to SmallPie
At SmallPie, located in Milwaukee, every dish tells a story of culinary passion and authenticity. This charming eatery is renowned for its handcrafted pies—both savory and sweet—alongside a delightful array of sandwiches. The warm and inviting atmosphere welcomes guests, including furry friends, making it a haven for all. Customers rave about the blueberry turkey sandwich and the remarkable handpies, underscoring the restaurant’s commitment to using fresh, locally sourced ingredients. With top-notch service and a laid-back vibe, SmallPie embodies the essence of honest, delicious food. It’s a hidden gem in Bayview, where flavors come alive and every bite feels like home.
SmallPie: Reviews & Ratings
Local and every day lavishly honest foods and flavors without pretension or arrogance just right for everyone! Great pies, savory and sweet. Sandwiches equally good. Please come to Denver!
The service is top notch, the blueberry turkey sandwich is something I tried on a whim and it’s my favorite now! Do yourself a favor and try it!
good coffee, great spot and I had a really delicious and well prepared bacon egg and cheese croissant! service is quite good.
Delicious handcraft foods and out of this world desserts and yes pie! Also, incredibly dog friendly was so nice to be able to bring my puppy and my friends at the same time to this hidden gem of Bayview and all the Milwaukee.
What a laid back restaurant with outdoor seating. We had the handpies. They were awesome!! Staff was friendly and helpful
Yes! I'm a big fan. I love the simplicity of this place and its warm, neighborly vibe. I live nearby, so it's incredibly convenient to have such a gem in the neighborhood. The menu isn’t huge, but that’s part of the charm. It changes frequently—even hourly at times—because everything is made fresh. You can really taste the quality. Their savory pies are consistently excellent, and the desserts are just as good. Honestly, I don’t think you can go wrong with anything on offer. There’s outdoor seating available, which makes for a nice spot to relax. Overall, this place continues to be a favorite.
Very nice quint place to stop, have been past in a few times and thought I would stop, nice pleasant staff and excellent pies,next time will try their food, a must stop
The food was great, service was good and loved the plants. Will be going here again and it’s a great stop if you’re going for a walk in the area.
Location
-
2504 E Oklahoma Ave, Milwaukee, WI 53207, United States Hotline: +1 414-763-7067
If you're in Milwaukee and looking for a delightful culinary experience, look no further than SmallPie. Tucked away at 2504 E Oklahoma Ave, this eatery is a hidden gem known for its unpretentious atmosphere and lavishly honest flavors. With a menu that balances savory pies, delectable sandwiches, and irresistible desserts, SmallPie stands out for its emphasis on quality ingredients and heartwarming recipes that cater to everyone.
One of the shining stars on the menu is the Sunday Hot Ham & Rolls, offered at just $15 and perfect for sharing or savoring all to yourself. Customers rave about the artistry in their hand-crafted foods, from the sweet to the savory, showcasing a creative flair without sacrificing comfort. Reviewers like Scot Przybylski have praised the pies and sandwiches as "great" and "equally good," highlighting the balanced offerings of this cozy establishment.
- Handcrafted Pies: Savory and sweet options that appeal to every palate.
- Sandwich Variety: Unique choices like the blueberry turkey sandwich, which has become a favorite for many visitors.
- Dog-Friendly Space: A welcoming environment where you can enjoy a meal alongside your furry friend.
- Outdoor Seating: A laid-back ambiance that enhances the dining experience.
As for the beverages, Derek Brown mentions the good coffee, creating an excellent pairing with meals, especially the famed bacon egg and cheese croissant. The overall service quality also garnered compliments, ensuring that your visit is as relaxed and enjoyable as your meal. Whether you're looking for a quick bite or a leisurely afternoon, SmallPie offers everything you need to satisfy your cravings while feeling at home.
Overall, SmallPie represents not just a dining option but an experience rich in flavor and warmth. It’s no surprise that customers are left wanting to spread the word about this Bayview treasure. Plan your visit today and discover just how delightful comfort food can be!